Application Whitelisting

Application Whitelisting is a security practice that allows only pre-approved (whitelisted) applications to execute on a system, while all other software is blocked by default. This approach significantly enhances security in Operational Technology (OT) environments by preventing unauthorized or malicious applications from running, thereby safeguarding critical infrastructure from cyberattacks.

Importance of Application Whitelisting in OT

OT systems, such as Industrial Control Systems (ICS), SCADA systems, and Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs), often require high uptime and reliability. Application whitelisting supports these objectives by:

• Minimizing Malware Risks: Blocks unauthorized applications, including malware and ransomware, from executing.
  Example: Preventing a malicious payload from altering PLC operations.
• Mitigating Insider Threats: Ensures trusted users cannot execute unauthorized applications or scripts.
• Protecting Legacy Systems: Adds a layer of protection for older OT devices lacking modern security features.
• Enhancing System Integrity: Restricts changes to the operating environment, ensuring only verified applications run.
• Supporting Compliance: Meets regulatory requirements like IEC 62443 and NERC-CIP by enforcing strict application controls.

How Application Whitelisting Works

1. Application Inventory: Create an inventory of all applications used in the OT environment, including operating system utilities, device drivers, and ICS software.
2. Whitelist Creation: Approve applications based on policies such as digital signatures, file hashes, or paths.
3. Execution Control: Enforce the whitelist, allowing only approved applications to execute. Unapproved applications are blocked, and alerts may be generated.
4. Monitoring and Updates: Continuously monitor the whitelist and update it to include patches, upgrades, and new operational requirements.

Benefits of Application Whitelisting in OT

• Improved Security Posture: Prevents execution of malicious code.
  Example: Blocking a ransomware executable not included in the whitelist.
• Operational Stability: Reduces disruptions by preventing unauthorized software from interfering with critical processes.
• Reduced Attack Surface: Eliminates vulnerabilities tied to unapproved applications.
• Simplified Management: Centralizes control over permitted software, aiding audits and compliance.
• Efficient Resource Use: Decreases reliance on antivirus systems by preemptively blocking unknown applications.

Challenges of Application Whitelisting in OT

• Initial Setup Complexity: Developing a comprehensive whitelist can be time-consuming in environments with many devices.
• Legacy Systems: Older OT systems may lack compatibility with whitelisting tools.
• Operational Disruption: Overly restrictive policies may block legitimate applications, causing downtime.
• Frequent Updates: Whitelists must be regularly updated to accommodate new software or patches.
• User Resistance: Operators may resist restrictions that appear to hinder productivity.

Best Practices for Implementing Application Whitelisting in OT

1. Start with a Pilot Program: Test whitelisting on non-critical systems before full deployment.
2. Comprehensive Application Inventory: Audit all existing applications to minimize disruptions.
3. Use Baseline Configurations: Establish device settings to ensure only required applications are whitelisted.
4. Regular Updates: Update the whitelist promptly to reflect software patches and operational changes.
5. Monitor and Log Activity: Record attempted execution of non-whitelisted applications for security and operational insights.
6. Involve Stakeholders: Collaborate with operators, engineers, and IT/OT personnel to identify necessary applications.
7. Combine with Other Controls: Complement whitelisting with measures such as network segmentation, firewalls, and intrusion detection systems (IDS).

Use Cases for Application Whitelisting in OT

• Industrial Control Systems (ICS): Ensures only verified software runs on PLCs, RTUs, and SCADA systems.
• Critical Infrastructure: Blocks unauthorized applications in systems managing energy grids, water treatment plants, and transportation networks.
• Remote Maintenance: Allows only approved remote access tools to reduce the risk of remote attacks.
• Regulated Environments: Meets compliance requirements for secure software execution in industries like energy, healthcare, and manufacturing.

Tools and Technologies for Application Whitelisting

• Microsoft AppLocker: A built-in Windows tool for application control.
• Carbon Black: Offers application control solutions for IT and OT environments.
• Ivanti Application Control: Centralized management for whitelisting in hybrid IT/OT environments.
• McAfee Application Control: Enforces whitelisting on critical OT systems.
• Symantec Endpoint Protection: Includes whitelisting features to block unauthorized applications.

Regulatory Frameworks Supporting Application Whitelisting

• NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF): Aligns with the Protect function, emphasizing unauthorized access prevention.
• IEC 62443: Advocates for authenticated and authorized software execution in industrial systems.
• NERC-CIP: Requires strict controls over software execution for critical energy infrastructure.

Conclusion

Application whitelisting is a robust security practice for OT environments, offering effective protection against unauthorized software execution. While initial implementation may pose challenges, following best practices and utilizing appropriate tools can ensure success. By restricting execution to a trusted list of applications, organizations can enhance security, operational stability, and compliance in their OT systems, ultimately reducing the risk of cyberattacks.

‍